menu

High Court grants permission to appeal decision over trans waiting times

Birmingham Pride’s Eva Echo has revealed that following the high court ruling in a case regarding NHS waiting times for transgender patients, an application to appeal the judgement has now been given permission.

The NHS has a statutory requirement that at least 92% of patients should be referred to a specialist within 18 weeks, and claimants in this case argued that NHS England breaks the law when they fail to meet this target for transgender patients. Last month, a judgement was handed down in which the High Court judge found that this ‘target’ duty was not a ‘legal’ duty; meaning that individuals could not enforce it as a right. Eva Echo announced the intent to appeal this ruling; an appeal that has now been granted permission.

Of the appeal, the judge, Mr Justice Chamberlain, stated, “There is a real prospect that the Court of Appeal might differ from the reasoning at [91]-[99] of my judgement. In any event, the point is of sufficient general importance to justifying consideration by the Court of Appeal.”

In social media posts, sharing the news, Eva Echo explained: “The High Court has granted us permission to appeal the decision over NHS England 18-week referral to treatment (RTT) target.

“It is incredibly rare for a High Court Judge to grant permission to appeal their own judgement… which shows just how important this case is. If successful, it could even set a precedent for excessive waiting times in other area of healthcare.”

To support with the Court of Appeal case, a crowdfunder has also been set up so that those in the position to do so can help cover the legal costs.

Birmingham LGBT+ Centre targeted with queerphobic graffiti

During LGBT+ History Month, Birmingham’s inclusive hub, the LGBT centre, was vandalised with homophobic graffiti. Staff working at Birmingham LGBT Centre – a leading charity advocating for and support the lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans and queer community in Birmingham and neighbouring authorities – were dismayed to see an offensive, vulgar and queerphobic message scratched into the glass of their front door on Monday, February 6. The graffiti, which cannot be removed easily, has temporarily been covered with a Pride flag until the centre can arrange a permanent removal.

Management at the LGBT+ centre have reported the incident to West Midlands Police. Anyone with any information regarding the homophobic vandalism is being urged to contact the police to report it.

Steph Keeble, director of Birmingham LGBT, told I Am Bham, “People felt upset at the vandalism and angry at the damage to the LGBT centre we had our windows put through twice in lockdown.

“I feel really cross that this has happened again we have worked hard to make sure the community have a safe space and this level of violation and vandalism is not acceptable, it is clearly a hate crime and clearly motivated by hate, and I don’t think it’s okay that staff or service users should be greeted with that when they arrive at the building.

“It’s also an additional expense to fix it that we don’t need as a small charity. I have told the staff to cover it with a rainbow flag until we can get it fixed so we can reclaim our pride in our centre.

“I think there has been an increase in homophobic, biphobia and transphobic hate crime over the last few years. Birmingham LGBT as an organisation supporting LGBTQ+ people have experienced three incidents of criminal damage. Our windows were broken twice during lockdown when no other business in the area were targeted, and a number of incidents of malicious communication in the last couple of years.”

Steph adds: “My message to the LGBTQ+ community in Birmingham this LGBT History month is stay strong, stay safe and be proud. The LGBT centre will continue to open and serve our community and we wish you all a safe and fun LGBT+ History Month.”

Birmingham vigil for Brianna Ghey attacked by LGBTQ+ hate

On Friday, February 17, people in Birmingham came together to hold a vigil for Brianna Ghey – a transgender teenage girl who was murdered in Warrington – but prior to the event, those already gathered were barraged with anti-LGBTQ+ hate.

The Birmingham vigil – which was just one of many across the UK being held to mourn Brianna and unite in supporting trans right – was held in Hippodrome Square, beside the newly erected HIV and AIDS Memorial, and it saw a large crowd of people coming together; showcasing the power of numbers. Ahead of the vigil’s start, however, the news outlet I Am Birmingham caught on camera the moment that the community was attacked with anti-LGBTQ+ hate.

Trans rights activist and Birmingham Pride’s Director of Innovation, Eva Echo, was being interviewed by I Am Birmingham when a group of teenage boys arrived at Hippodrome Square and began shouting slurs, homophobic, and transphobic abuse. There were also reports that one of the teenagers was carrying a knife. Southside security staff eventually managed to usher them away before the vigil was held, allowing the community the gather in peace.

During the interview, Eva Echo was telling I Am Birmingham, “You’ve got the media that constantly attacks trans people, you’ve got MPs in the House of Commons who mirror that language and it sets a very dangerous precedent because it normalises transphobia, allowing people to basically take it upon themselves to speak out and take action against the trans community.” Eva was then interrupted by shouts of anti-LGBTQ+ hate, which she later stated only proved her point.

Eva said, “[This is the] first time I’ve ever been interrupted during an interview. Sadly, this is the reality of being LGBTQ+ and it’s exactly why we have so much work to do – especially to tackle misinformation, lies and ignorant attitudes which lead to people being radicalised by hate.

“I urge all mainstream media/press to report responsibly and accurate. Stop placing clicks, sales and ignorant journalism over real human lives. Words, misinformation and lies can kill just as much as knives can. The loss of Brianna’s life is proof of that.”

Speaking about the vigil itself, Eva Echo added, “I just want to say a huge thank you from me and the other organisers of last night’s vigil in Birmingham. The area was packed with hundreds of people coming together to remember Brianna and to stand with the trans community. Thank you to all the speakers for your powerful words, which remind us just how important visibility and stepping up can be, if we wish to see change. The vigils are proof that we can come together and that when we do, we are powerful.”

Joe Lycett to host new series of live shows from Birmingham

Following the success of Channel 4’s Joe Lycett’s Big Pride Party, a new live show series with the working title of The Joe Lycett Live Show has been commissioned by the broadcaster. The weekly Friday night comedy show will be hosted by the award-winning comedian Joe Lycett, live from Birmingham, with a live audience and celebrity guests.

Following a similar style to Joe Lycett’s Big Pride Party – for which Joe is nominated for a National Comedy Award – this new series will feature a mix of Joe’s community of local legends, LGBTQ+ heroes and allies will join him alongside celebrities and big-name guests from the worlds of comedy, television, music and film.

A statement from Channel 4 says: “With inclusivity and fun at its heart, the series will see Joe take a look back at the week in a way only he can – combining his unique brand of mischief and mayhem with his singular style of comedy. Shot on the banks of Birmingham’s canals, the show will bring a touch of Hollywood sparkle to Digbeth in a big night of unmissable entertainment.”

Speaking about the show, Lycett said: “I’m absolutely psyched and naturally very nervous about hosting a weekly live show from Birmingham, but it has been a dream of mine for many years and I look forward to some (controlled) late night chaos.”

While Steve Handley, Commissioning Editor, added: “We are thrilled that Joe will be bringing his personal brand of mayhem to Friday nights and can’t wait to see his take on the events of the week, live from the canal banks of Birmingham.”

Joe Lycett will be broadcasting live from his hometown of Birmingham on Friday nights for five weeks, for these brand-new 60-minute comedy shows. No start date has been released.

Wolverhampton Pride to return “bigger and better than ever” in 2023

After a four-year absence, Wolverhampton Pride is returning to the city “bigger and better than ever” on Saturday, June 10 from 12 – 10pm in School Street; the heart of the city’s LGBTQ+ community.

Wolverhampton Pride has, for the last 12 months, been consulting with members of the LGBTQ+ community to find out what Pride means to them. Organisers of the event have incorporated this feedback in the planning, format and timing of this year’s event.

They say: “We have proudly been working with Enjoy Wolverhampton Business Improvement District, Gorgeous Nightclub, Gorgeous Radio, Wolverhampton LGBT and X2Y.”

Those attending Wolverhampton Pride 2023 can expect a parade, main stage with live music, drag artists and DJs, food, bars, community stalls, face painting, a quiet area and more.

The organisers added: “Wolverhampton Pride is a celebration of our city’s LGBTQ+ community and is open to everyone to come and support LGBTQ+ inclusion together.”

The first release of tickets for Wolverhampton Pride are available online now from EventBrite – prices are £3 for adults and £1.50 for concessions (12-17, over 65s, disabled people and their carer), while under 12s go free.

More details regarding the line-up and the parade route will be announced soon via the Wolverhampton Pride website and on their Facebook page.

Birmingham’s Southside unveils strategy to support its future as a diverse cultural centre

Southside Business Improvement District (Southside BID) – home to Birmingham’s gay village – has unveiled an ambitious new strategic vision which aims to “drive economic growth and support its future development as a diverse cultural centre”.

This strategy will see three connected plans – covering access to transport, festivals and events, and Southside’s potential to become a Cultural Action Zone – come together to transform the area. The BID has worked with local businesses and key city stakeholders to propose a series of strategic and practical recommendations as part of their vision.

A press release explains: “Southside’s Access Strategy sets out new proposals to transform Hurst Street at the heart of the district into a space which is far more welcoming for pedestrians, cyclists and disabled people. This bold strategy will see a wholesale redesign of the current streetscape, removing kerbs, parking spaces and the separation between road space and pedestrian space to promote café culture and pedestrianising Hurst Street at night, reducing vehicle based anti-social behaviour. The strategy also seeks to make cycling routes safer and more user friendly, and introduce more green infrastructure into the district.”

The second plan in their vision covering festivals and events, aims to combat the city centre’s reduced footfall, which is still below pre-pandemic levels.

“Southside’s Festival & Events Strategy proposes a series of recommendations to support the return of major events to the district, enabling Southside to create a meaningful sense of place as well as contributing to the social, cultural and economic growth of the area.

“As the cultural heart of Birmingham, and home to a number of significant festivals including Birmingham Pride, Chinese New Year and Summer in Southside, the recommendations include the protection of a large open space within Southside, the creation of a festivals committee that can work together on funding applications and share learnings and insights, the appointment of a part-time coordinator who can support Birmingham’s creative network and encourage more festivals activity and the creation of an evaluation team who can monitor the social and economic impact.”

Closely connected to this strategy is the BID’s proposal to become a Cultural Action Zone, “positioning the district as a leader of world-class cultural events and visitor experiences with diverse communities and engagement at its heart.”

“Designed to create thriving areas for people to live, work and visit, Cultural Action Zones are a key driver to invigorate the economic recovery of city centres.”

Lawrence Barton, chair of Southside BID and Director of Birmingham Pride, said, “The pedestrianisation of Southside is something I’ve always been passionate about. Our vision as a BID is for Southside to be Birmingham’s Covent Garden – and I know we’re hardly there yet – but pedestrianising the area would be a big, positive step towards that.

Barton believes that pedestrianising the area may also help reduce hate crime in the area. He explains that, “upsettingly, we’ve also seen a continuation of drive-by hate crime in the area over the past year. I’ve had staff working at my venues who’ve had abuse hurled at them and things thrown at them from car windows.

For people living, working and visiting the district, having more open space would make the area safe and more pleasant.”

More information regarding all the strategies in this vision can be found on Southside BID’s website.

Fatt Butcher’s ‘Anywhere is a Dancefloor’ to release online

Anywhere is a Dancefloor, created by Adam Carver (AKA Fatt Butcher), is a queer music video featuring many local talents reclaiming public spaces across Birmingham’s city centre. The video, which was submitted to many film festivals, will be having its online release on Friday, February 17 at 7pm.

The award-winning film won Best LGBT Pride Celebration Film at Color’s of Love International Queer Film Festival, India and the Best Short Film Award at G.L.A.D. Film Festival. As part of its release, supporters, friends and family will be able to join a watch party with the Motion Dance Collective who produced the film for the Birmingham International Dance Festival.

The choreography was created by Jason Andrew Guest who appeared in the video as Luna Myztique, alongside the other dancers including; RuPaul‘s Drag Race UK’s Black Peppa, Chanda John, Joey Taylor, Simone Mendez, Sammy Lawrence, Jay Andre, Christian Gay, Lacey McFadyen, Blü Romantic, Yshee Black, and, of course, Fatt Butcher. For more information, follow the Motion Dance Collective on Instagram.

Birmingham’s Eva Echo announces intention to appeal High Court ruling over transgender NHS waiting times

A group, including Birmingham Pride’s Eva Echo, has lost their legal case against NHS England over waiting times for transgender patients to be seen by a gender dysphoria specialist.

The NHS has a statutory requirement that at least 92% of patients should be referred to a specialist within 18 weeks, and claimants argued that NHS England has broken the law when they have failed to meet this target for transgender patients. However, the High Court judge in the case found that this ‘target’ duty is not a ‘legal’ duty, which means that individuals cannot enforce this as a right.

Following the news of the High Court judge’s ruling, Eva Echo said: “I’m extremely disappointed by the decisions overall, which only serve to prolong the mental health suffering of the trans community.

“Reading the judgement, it seems to me the Judge didn’t quite get it. For example, he referenced other areas being affected if funding was diverted to improve trans healthcare. But this isn’t what we were asking for – there’s more than one way to spend the same money. In any event, if the duty is a target one, then there are no repercussions for NHS England if they don’t meet it. This leads to patients waiting indefinitely which, in my opinion, is inhumane. We disagree with the judgment, which is why we’ll be applying for the chance to appeal.”

Official statistics show there are over 26,000 adults waiting for their first appointment with an adult gender dysphoria clinic, and of those people, over 23,500 have been waiting more than 18 weeks.

Eva Echo did, however, share some positive news that has come from the High Court case. She explains, “NHS England tried to argue trans youths couldn’t yet make their mind up about gender reassignment and therefore wouldn’t be a protected characteristic under the Equality Act. The Judge deemed trans youths are if they’d already started to transition in any way. As such, they are a protected characteristic and covered under the Equality Act against discrimination. As far as I know, this is the first time it’s been included in a legally binding judgment.

“No matter what happens from here, please know that trans voices were heard at a high level during this case.”

Eva continues: “We’ve created so much awareness of the impact it’s having on thousands of people. We collectively took a stand to say we are here and we cannot be silenced. Massive thanks to Good Law Project and the entire legal team for their hard work and dedication. This isn’t the end. We will keep fighting because healthcare is a human right.”

Nominees for Gaydio Pride Awards 2023 announced

Gaydio – the LGBTQ+ station for the UK – has revealed the nominees for their 2023 Pride Awards.

Birmingham Pride and Brighton & Hove Pride are nominated for Major Pride of the Year, alongside Manchester Pride and Pride in London. Birmingham Women’s and Children’s NHS Trust LGBT+ Staff Network is nominated for the Pride Network of the Year category, while The Werkroom in Stoke-on-Trent is a nominee for Venue or Event of the Year.

Trans Pride Brighton, the first and largest Trans Pride event in Europe, is a nominee for Grassroots Pride of the Year along with UK Black Pride and Chesterfield Pride.

Nominations could be made by anyone before the deadline on December 4, and then it was up to the Community Panel who are responsible for deciding the shortlist of nominees, and then the winners of each category (apart from the Music Artist of the Year, which is voted on by Gaydio listeners).

“The community panel are independent of Gaydio and work across a variety of sectors both publicly and privately,” explains the Gaydio Pride Awards website. For the 2023 awards, this panel is made up of Lady Phyll, Dr Carl Austin-Behan, Ste Dunn, and Danielle St James.

The Gaydio Pride Awards with Hilton will be held on Friday, February 10 at the Hilton in Manchester. Further information about the various categories, nominees, and entertainment for the evening can be found online.

Birmingham’s HIV and AIDS ‘Cover Up Quilts’ exhibition opened by activist Jonathan Blake

Birmingham’s Cover Up Quilts are an Arts Council-funded community project conceived by local artist Garry Jones, who also founded the Ribbons Birmingham HIV and AIDS Memorial. Inspired by the original NAMES memorial quilt which began in San Francisco in 1985, this project saw the creation of over 50 quilt panels designed to educate, destigmatise, and commemorate those lost to AIDS.

The panels have now gone on display in Centenary Square, in an exhibition that was opened by artist Garry Jones, activist Jonathan Blake, Saving Lives’ Dr Steve Taylor, and Positive PeersRachel Greaves. The quilt panels will remain on display across the Centenary Square venues – Symphony Hall, The Exchange, the Rep Theatre, and City Library – until the end of January, at which point, they will be moved to BCU’s Millennium Point. The exhibition is open daily; however, you will need to check the venues for their opening hours.

Jonathan Blake, Dr Steve, Garry Jones

Each quilt panel has been conceived and designed by a variety of groups and artists; from individuals, to organisations, from charities to universities. The volunteer group Sew Marvellous acted as quality control, which allowed groups of non-sewers to be involved in the panel creations, before they then spent hours stitching the quilts to life.

Gill from Sew Marvellous

These works of art explore a diverse range of aspects from the history of HIV and AIDS in Birmingham, the UK and internationally, including: access to PrEP, the Don’t Die of Ignorance campaign, and the groups of lesbians who helped care for HIV+ gay men, known as The Blood Sisters. Other quilt panels are more personal, commemorating loved ones.

More information about each of the panels, their designers, artists and sewers, as well as more information about the project itself can be found in the exhibition’s guide book, which is available to purchase for £10 from Birmingham City Library. Proceeds will help support the ongoing work of Birmingham AIDS and HIV Memorial and Cover Up Quilt Project.

X